Best medium car over $50,000
Mercedes Benz C250 CDI
Winners and scores
You expect a Mercedes Benz to feel bullet proof and indestructible. The C Class lives up to that lofty expectation, yet also delivers a level of refinement and elegance that is almost unmatched in any class.
Inside, there’s quality everywhere, from switchgear and controls to surface finishes and material. Comfort levels are high, as is standard safety, which includes all the airbags you’d expect and every conceivable electronic driving aid.
In terms of space, the C Class is the equal of the BMW 320D and stronger than the VW Passat CC (both fellow finalists), while its ergonomics are just about best in class.
Mercedes Benz has almost made its general model range look more AMG than ever, and in the case of the attractive C Class sedan, this styling mandate makes the most sense of all. Importantly, inside and out, it looks like you have spent a whole lot more money than you actually have.
On road, the diesel engine is brilliant but it’s almost overshadowed by the slick shifting and silky smooth, seven-speed auto transmission, which always seems to find the right ratio to keep the ‘oiler’ in the meat of its torque curve.
Handling, braking, ride and general on-road performance are all class leading.

Manufacturer’s List Price: $67,900
Criteria out of 10 – Mercedes Benz C250 CDI Avantgarde
Value for
Money |
Rating |
Pricing |
6H |
Depreciation |
7M |
Running Costs |
5M |
Fuel Consumption |
10H |
Warranty and dealer access |
4M |
Insurance |
5L |
Standard Features |
6H |
Design and
Function |
Rating |
Safety |
10C |
Environment |
8C |
Comfort |
9H |
Space |
7M |
Practicality |
8M |
Ergonomics |
8H |
Build and Finish |
9C |
On the
Road |
Rating |
Performance |
9H |
Ride |
9H |
Handling |
9C |
Braking |
9C |
Smoothness and Quietness |
8H |
Note: Level of weighting importance for each score: L = Low, M = Medium, H = High, C =
Critical.